In JW Acquisitions, LLC v. Shulman, (Del. Ch., Oct 25. 2006), read opinion here , the Chancery Court addressed how a summary proceeding under the DGCL interfaces with related proceedings among the same or similar parties pending in other states. This 17-page opinion could be the answer to a bar exam question on esoteric
Court of Chancery Updates
Declaratory Judgments; Justiciability and Buyer’s Duties
In Energy Partners, Ltd. v. Stone Energy Corp., (Del. Ch., Oct. 11, 2006), read opinion here, the Chancery Court addressed whether the issue presented was ripe in the context of an expedited trial to interpret provisions of a merger agreement that was attacked on several fronts, including a third party that made a…
Delaware Dissolution Statute: NY Court’s Interpretation; and Blog Discussion of Cases
Though this blog focuses on Delaware decisions addressing business law topics, there are not nearly as many decisions on some parts of the relatively recent LLC statutes–compared with the bountiful case law on the DGCL. Thus, when a court of another state interprets those Delaware statutes it is worth a reference. See, e.g., Horning case I summarized here . [Aside:…
The Law and Economics of Blogs
Prof. Ribstein just published an article that discusses the law and economics of weblogs or blogs. He refers to blogs in the article as "amateur journalism", but as a leading blogger himself, on his blog named Ideoblog, he uses the term in a positive sense. Here is the link to his summary of the…
Laches; Mootness; Intervention; and Motion to Amend
In Franklin Balance Sheet Investment Fund v. Crowley, (Del. Ch., Oct. 19, 2006), read opinion here , the Chancery Court addressed the following issues in a case involving claims of fiduciary duty breaches, self-dealing and entrenchment:
1) Under Chancery Court Rule 15(aaa), the plaintiff must choose to rest on his complaint or amend it…
Court Costs Payable to Prevailing Party Under Rule 54(d)
In Dewey Beach Lions Club v. Longacre, et al., (Del. Ch., Oct. 11, 2006), read opinion here , the Chancery Court ruled on a post-trial "bill of costs" pursuant to Chancery Court Rule 54(d). This is the sort of practical letter opinion that I like to refer to as a useful reference tool for…
Hedge Fund Denied Data Under DGCL Section 220
In Polygon Global Opportunities Master Fund v. West Corp., 2006 WL 2947486 (Del. Ch., October 12, 2006), read opinion here, the Delaware Chancery Court addressed another request for books and records under DGCL Section 220 by a hedge fund and found it wanting, as explained in this thoroughly reasoned opinion. For another recent Chancery decision, Highland…
Breach of Forum Selection Clause May Support Award of Attorneys’ Fees
In Cornerstone Brands, Inc. v. O’Steen, read opinion here , the Chancellor discussed, among other things, the topic of forum selection clauses, which are routinely upheld in Delaware. The most noteworthy aspect of this opinion, which I predict will be an often cited opinion for this reason, held that a claim for attorneys’ fees could proceed …
Order Imposing Stay Remains in Place
In Davis International, LLC v. New Start Group Corp., read opinion here, the Chancery Court refused to lift its earlier stay in favor of pending federal proceedings, in reply to, in essence, a motion for reconsideration of an earlier decision in light of subsequent developments. Especially noteworthy at footnote 10 is a discussion of …
Covenant-Not-To-Compete Extended Due to Inevitable Disclosure and Untrustworthiness of Ex-Employee
In W.L. Gore & Associates, Inc. v. Wu, read opinion here, the Chancery Court addressed the right by a former employer, W.L. Gore & Associates, to restrict the use of its trade secrets by a former employee. The factual background of this case is very involved and is also set forth in two …