Chancery Orders Production of Purportedly Privileged Report of Corporate Counsel; Metadata also Required

In Ryan v. Gifford,  (Del Ch., Nov. 30, 2007), read opinion here, the Chancery Court ordered the production of a report that a company’s lawyers provided to a special committee of the board, finding that the privilege was waived when a copy was sent to the whole board, some of whose members were the subject of the derivative suit involved. Hat tip to Skadden’s Paul Lockwood via Harvard’s Corporate Governance Blog, who has a summary of the decision on that blog.

For all the e-discovery fans among you, the court also required the production of metadata for documents that were related to the backdated stock option claims, for at least 2 reasons:

(i) the metadata would have information about the dates of drafts of the documents related to the allegedly backdated options; and

(ii) the special committee’s investigation apparently included a review of the metadata.

Here is a link to summaries of the prior two decisions by the court in this case.

  • http://www.delawarelitigation.com/2008/01/articles/chancery-court-updates/request-for-interlocutory-appeal-denied-regarding-production-of-special-litigation-committee-files/index.html Delaware Corporate and Commercial Litigation Blog

    Request for Interlocutory Appeal Denied Regarding Production of Special Litigation Committee Files

    Ryan v. Gifford, 2008 WL 43699 (Del. Ch., Jan. 2, 2008), read opinion here, is the first reported Delaware Chancery Court decision of 2008 and follows three prior decisions in this case, which were summarized here, here and here. The…

  • http://www.delawarelitigation.com/2008/10/articles/chancery-court-updates/chancery-decides-important-electronic-discovery-issues/index.html Delaware Corporate and Commercial Litigation Blog

    Chancery Decides Important Electronic Discovery Issues

    Kinexus US Representative LLC v. Advent Software, Inc. (Del. Ch., Sept. 22, 2008), read opinion here. In this Chancery Court decision, that decided cross motions to compel discovery, the Court addressed important and practical issues involving electron…